Regulation and Behaviour in Early Childhood: Four Shifts for Calmer Days | EarlyChildhoodEduNet
Hub 1: Regulation and Behaviour

Regulation and Behaviour in Early Childhood: Four Shifts for Calmer Days

Mastering regulation and behaviour in early childhood begins with asking whether a young child’s outward actions are communicating how their body and nervous system are coping, rather than assuming they are conscious moral choices.

The Core Operational Definition

In this framework, I use regulation and behaviour in early childhood to mean the link between how a child’s body and nervous system are coping and what the child does. When a child bolts, bites, collapses, or refuses a spoken transition, one possibility is that they are overwhelmed.

In my experience, lasting change usually starts with adults helping the child feel safe before expecting instructions or social rules to be followed.

Regulation and behaviour in early childhood: minimalist storybook illustration of educator co-regulating with a child on timber floor

The Biological Reality of Regulation and Behaviour in Early Childhood

When addressing regulation and behaviour in early childhood, mainstream discourse often separates a child’s internal emotional state from the observable actions taking place in the room. A child who throws materials across a table or refuses to sit on the group mat is often categorised as exhibiting oppositional, challenging, or attention seeking conduct.

A common response is to apply behavioural redirection, logical consequences, or extrinsic token economies.

However, behaviour is not only a matter of choice. Research on early brain development indicates that the skills young children need to manage strong feelings and impulses, such as executive function and inhibition, are still developing through the early years and beyond, and that stress can make them harder to use.[1]

Harvard’s research group on early brain development makes a point I come back to often: the skills children use to manage big feelings and impulses are still being built in the early years, and living with threatening situations for a long time can get in the way of that.[1]

In everyday terms, a very stressed child often finds it harder to think flexibly, listen, and wait. Many people describe this as the body’s stress response taking over.

When a child is very distressed, language is often one of the first things to become hard. Demanding that a child explain their feelings in the middle of an emotional storm is often asking too much of them.

Within Australian early learning systems, the Early Years Learning Framework (EYLF) V2.0 names secure, respectful and reciprocal relationships as a core principle, and children’s wellbeing as one of its learning outcomes.[2]

Looking at regulation and behaviour in early childhood with this in mind fits that emphasis. We stop assuming distress is wilful disruption and begin asking what might be pushing the child outside their window of tolerance.

The Breakdown of Extrinsic Compliance Systems

Traditional early learning environments and domestic routines frequently rely on operant conditioning: star charts, traffic light behaviour ladders, time outs, and loss of playground privileges. These approaches rest on a premise I question: that a dysregulated child possesses the baseline neurological control to calculate costs and benefits in the middle of a physiological crisis.

For some neurodivergent children, including some with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), autism, or auditory processing differences, I have found that these systems often backfire. Reward systems suit some children well; the question I ask is whether they suit this child on this day.

I should be upfront: the research is kinder to reward systems than my own experience has been. Reviews of behavioural approaches for ADHD report good results, and a review of token systems in primary classrooms found large effects, although it did not say which children had which diagnoses.[5][6]

What I describe next is narrower, and I have not found research that tests it, so please take it as what I have noticed in practice. When an overwhelmed child sees their marker moved to red on a classroom wall, the public exposure can feel like social danger, and in my experience it can push some children towards fight, flight, or shutdown instead of self-correction.

The table below sets out my own reading and experience, not a summary of research findings.

Conventional Compliance Model What May Be Happening Instead What I Have Seen Happen
Assumption of Wilful Choice: Assumes the child decides whether to follow instructions. An Involuntary Stress Reaction: Under strong stress, a child may not be able to use skills such as stopping and thinking, even if they can use them on a calm day. Shame; some children come to believe they are bad or defective.
Extrinsic Motivators: Uses stickers, praise, or point deductions to drive desired actions. Delayed Rewards May Not Motivate Some Children: Research suggests that, on average, people with ADHD pick a smaller reward now over a bigger one later a little more often than others do. The effect is small to medium, and nobody is sure why.[7] A chart may work on easy days and fall apart on hard ones.
Verbal Processing Demand: Requires immediate explanation: “Use your words, why did you do that?” Talking Gets Harder: Many children find it much harder to put feelings into words when they are very distressed. Can escalate the distress or lead to the child going silent.

Sustainable regulation and behaviour in early childhood cannot be built upon intimidation, public humiliation, or reward manipulation. In my experience, predictable, grounded adult co-regulation is one of the most important supports for helping a child build self-regulation over time. Stuart Shanker’s Self-Reg work takes a similar view.[3]

For practical steps on handling acute emotional stress without coercion, review our guide on child meltdown co-regulation.

Mapping Observable States: A Polyvagal Lens

To make sense of difficult behaviour, it helps to have a simple map of observable states. Polyvagal theory, developed by Stephen Porges, offers one: a child’s state is described as an internal colour wheel that shifts in response to neuroception, the brain’s unconscious detection of safety and threat.[4]

The theory is popular with practitioners but contested: Grossman (2023) argues that its basic premises do not hold up, and Neuhuber and Berthoud (2022) check it against what is known about the vagus nerve.[8][9]

I use it here as a descriptive lens for naming what I see, not as established physiology.

  • 1. Ventral Vagal State (Social Engagement & Active Learning) Heart rate is stable, breathing is steady, and the facial muscles are relaxed. The child can make eye contact, listen to instructions, share toys, and tolerate small changes in the routine. Learning design is naturally received here.
  • 2. Sympathetic Mobilisation (Fight or Flight) Triggered by noise, perceived injustice, sensory overload, or sudden demands. Through this lens, you may see more motor agitation, a louder voice, and tense muscles. Behaviour manifests as hitting, sprinting from the room, shouting, or defensive arguing.
  • 3. Dorsal Vagal Collapse (Freeze or Shutdown) Through this lens, when struggle fails or demands become unmanageable, the child may collapse inward. The child drops their head to the desk, stares blankly into space, goes limp, or refuses to speak. This state can be mistaken for passive defiance.

Using this lens has changed how I respond day to day. When an educator recognises fight or flight, they can drop the acoustic demands in the room and lower their physical body instead of delivering a lecture on kindness.

When a parent recognises shutdown, they can sit quietly beside the child on the floor instead of threatening to take away bedtime stories, and offer steady, silent company until the child settles.

Four Core Guides for Educators and Parents

To help early childhood professionals, support workers, and families put these ideas into daily practice, this hub is organised around four practical guides:

De-escalation Protocol

Child Meltdowns & Co-Regulation

A step by step physical procedure for handling acute emotional storms without power struggles, verbal interrogations, or harmful isolation.

Read Guide →
Systemic Flaw Analysis

ADHD Behaviour Strategies: Why Behaviour Charts Fail

An honest examination of why visual reward ladders backfire during executive dysfunction, and sustainable alternatives that preserve connection.

Read Guide →
Nervous System Decoder

Fight, Flight, and Freeze in Children Decoded

How to notice signs of overload in the classroom or at home before they build into full distress.

Read Guide →
Somatic Scripts & Proximity

Co-Regulation Strategies for Early Childhood

Physical postures, proximity, and calming vocal tones adults can use to help a child feel safe in chaotic moments.

Read Guide →

One of the most common flashpoints in early childhood rooms is group time. If a child keeps leaving the mat, my guide to when a child won’t sit for circle time walks through what to notice, whether anything needs to change, and what to try.

Environmental Pressures: The Silent Triggers of Dysregulation

An indispensable principle of regulation and behaviour in early childhood is that children are affected by their physical surroundings. A child’s capacity to manage strong feelings does not exist in isolation; it is shaped by the architectural, acoustic, and visual features of the room.

In some early learning centres and classrooms, children can be exposed to a heavy load of sensory input, such as:

  • High frequency acoustic reverberation bouncing off polished linoleum floors and bare drywall.
  • Visual noise generated by saturated wall displays, hanging mobiles, and open, uncurtained shelving.
  • Flicker from older fluorescent tube lighting.
  • Unpredictable, jarring auditory transitions, such as electric bells or amplified music cues.

For some neurodivergent children, differences in sensory processing may mean that coping with this environmental load takes a great deal of effort. Winnie Dunn’s model of sensory processing describes how people differ in their sensory thresholds and in how they respond to sensory input.[10]

In my experience, by mid morning some children’s sensory cup is overflowing, and a behavioural explosion at tidy up time may have little to do with the blocks on the carpet. It can be the breaking point of a child who has been coping all morning.

Rather than treating the resulting behaviour with discipline, intentional learning design modifies the room itself. To master the practical mechanics of environmental calming, review our detailed guides in the Sensory Environment Hub →

The Educator and Parent Capacity Equation

We cannot construct a realistic model of regulation and behaviour in early childhood without addressing the nervous system of the adult in the room. Co-regulation is not only a technique or a script recited from a manual. Children seem to pick up a great deal from an adult’s tone, face, and body.

Daniel Siegel describes how relationships shape the developing brain,[11] and I find this matches what I see: children often take their cue from the adult’s calm or tension.

An educator managing twenty two children while writing documentation, or an ADHD mother managing domestic logistics on four hours of sleep, cannot consistently access infinite patience. When adult energy drops to zero, the capacity to offer a grounded, non reactive presence evaporates.

  • The Fallacy of the Endless Co-Regulator: Adults are biological organisms with fluctuating energy thresholds. Expecting parents or teachers to remain permanently calm during relentless sensory chaos is unrealistic.
  • Dropping Demands to Preserve Adult Reserves: Sustainable learning design prioritises adult capacity preservation. When family or classroom energy is low, dropping unnecessary non safety expectations protects the shared emotional climate.
  • Navigating Asynchronous Adult-Child Capacity: When both the adult and the child are neurodivergent, co-regulation requires intentional environmental adjustments rather than superhuman willpower.

To understand how daily capacity swings affect both children and the adults who care for them, explore our framework deep-dive in the Spiky Profiles & Capacity Hub →

Where This Hub Sits in Our Learning Design Framework

The ideas and strategies in this hub are educational. They are not clinical psychotherapy, psychiatric intervention, or medical advice, and I am not an occupational therapist, clinical psychologist, speech pathologist or medical practitioner. They are a practical framework drawn from my experience and the sources below, written for early childhood educators and families navigating everyday environments.

In my experience, when I stopped viewing early childhood behaviour only as a discipline issue and began responding to it as communication about how a child is coping, daily friction dropped. Grounding learning routines in an understanding of child development can also help protect caregiver wellbeing and create spaces where more children feel safe, settled, and ready to learn.

Where this comes from: Written by Dr Dewi Griffith (PhD in Early Childhood Education, Deakin University), a former early childhood educator and NDIS support worker, and a parent with ADHD. This is educational content, not clinical advice.
How to read this page

Research: the Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University on executive function and stress. Guidance: the Early Years Learning Framework V2.0. Contested: polyvagal theory, which is widely used but disputed. Reviews of reward systems and delayed-reward choice are summarised, not tested against the conditions I describe.

Experience: the strategies, the comparison table and the examples come from my own practice. Last reviewed: 17 October 2026.

References

  1. National Scientific Council on the Developing Child. (2011). Building the brain’s “air traffic control” system: How early experiences shape the development of executive function (Working Paper No. 11). Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University. https://developingchild.harvard.edu/resources/building-the-brains-air-traffic-control-system/
  2. Australian Government Department of Education. (2022). Belonging, Being and Becoming: The Early Years Learning Framework for Australia (V2.0).
  3. Shanker, S. (2016). Self-Reg: How to Help Your Child (and You) Break the Stress Cycle and Successfully Engage with Life. Penguin Random House.
  4. Porges, S. W. (2011). The Polyvagal Theory: Neurophysiological Foundations of Emotions, Attachment, Communication, and Self-Regulation. W. W. Norton & Company. [A contested model, used here as a descriptive lens].
  5. Fabiano, G. A., Pelham, W. E., Coles, E. K., Gnagy, E. M., Chronis-Tuscano, A., & O’Connor, B. C. (2009). A meta-analysis of behavioral treatments for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Clinical Psychology Review, 29(2), 129–140. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19131150/
  6. Kim, J. Y., Fienup, D. M., Oh, A. E., & Wang, Y. (2022). Systematic review and meta-analysis of token economy practices in K–5 educational settings, 2000 to 2019. Behavior Modification, 46(6), 1460–1487. https://doi.org/10.1177/01454455211058077
  7. Marx, I., Hacker, T., Yu, X., Cortese, S., & Sonuga-Barke, E. (2021). ADHD and the choice of small immediate over larger delayed rewards: A comparative meta-analysis of performance on simple choice-delay and temporal discounting paradigms. Journal of Attention Disorders, 25(2), 171–187. https://doi.org/10.1177/1087054718772138
  8. Grossman, P. (2023). Fundamental challenges and likely refutations of the five basic premises of the polyvagal theory. Biological Psychology, 180, Article 108589. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2023.108589
  9. Neuhuber, W. L., & Berthoud, H.-R. (2022). Functional anatomy of the vagus system: How does the polyvagal theory comply? Biological Psychology, 174, Article 108425. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2022.108425
  10. Dunn, W. (2007). Living Sensationally: Understanding Your Senses. Jessica Kingsley Publishers. [Sensory processing thresholds and responses].
  11. Siegel, D. J. (2012). The Developing Mind: How Relationships and the Brain Interact to Shape Who We Are. Guilford Press. [Interpersonal neurobiology].
© 2026 EarlyChildhoodEduNet. Supporting neurodivergent families and early childhood educators across Australia and worldwide.

Similar Posts