Multilingual and EAL

The Silent Period in EAL Children: How a Multilingual Child Processes Their Expanding World

What is the silent period?

The silent period, sometimes called the non-verbal period, is a time when a young child learning a new language listens and watches much more than they speak. It’s a common, normal part of learning English as an additional language (EAL), and it’s usually far busier on the inside than it looks from the outside.

When my youngest daughter started Prep in Melbourne with almost no English, she went quiet at school for months. I worried she was lost. She was actually doing some of the hardest work of her young life.

Silent period in EAL children: a quiet multilingual child sits at the edge of the mat thinking of home, while an educator kneels beside her and other children chat in English
The silent period often looks like a child watching from the edges. Inside, they’re listening, learning and holding on to home.

Our Story: A Quiet Start to Prep

We moved from Jakarta to Melbourne in October 2010 so I could start a PhD in early childhood education. My eldest daughter was seven. My youngest, Zara, was nearly five, and in February 2011 she started Prep with very little English.

At home, Zara never stopped talking. We spoke Indonesian together, sang, laughed and planned our weekend trips to the shops. At school, she went quiet. She stood near the edges of the room, watched the other children closely and rarely said a word. When a classmate offered her something, she might take a small step back and look away.

I’ll be honest: I worried. It’s hard to watch your bright, chatty child go silent in a room full of noise. I wondered whether she was lonely, confused or falling behind, and whether I should push her to speak English.

What I learned, slowly, is that her silence wasn’t empty. She was listening, watching and working out how this new world worked. Months later, a drawing she brought home and one small word at a craft table showed me how much she’d been taking in. I share those moments in EAL identity and belonging. This post is about the quiet months before them, and what helps a child through them.

Silence in a new language is rarely empty. It’s often a child building a bridge between where they come from and where they are now.

What the Silent Period Is, and Why It Happens

Imagine being dropped into a busy room where everyone speaks a language you barely know. You’d probably watch and listen for a while before trying to say anything. Young children do the same.

Patton Tabors, who spent years studying young children learning English in preschool classrooms, described this quiet time as a common stage for children who arrive speaking another language.[1] Many children first try their home language, discover that others don’t understand it, and then go quiet while they listen and learn. They aren’t refusing to talk. They’re gathering what they need before they can.

Feelings play a big part too. Children who feel anxious or embarrassed often hold back, while children who feel safe tend to try more. Linguist Stephen Krashen described this as an “affective filter”, an idea that is widely used in teaching, though still debated by researchers.[2] Either way, the everyday lesson is the same: safety and warmth help words come. Australia’s Early Years Learning Framework puts the same idea at the centre of early learning, with belonging and a strong sense of identity as the starting point.[4]

The Four Stages of Learning English as a Young Child

Tabors described a sequence many young children move through when they learn English in an early learning setting.[1] Children don’t all move through it the same way or at the same speed, and some skip or blend stages. But it’s reassuring to see that the silent period is part of a path.

Stage What It Looks Like How Adults Can Help
1. Home language use The child speaks their home language at school, expecting to be understood. Respond warmly. Learn a few key words in their language.
2. Non-verbal period The child goes quiet, watching and listening, and communicates with gestures, pointing or facial expressions. Keep talking to them simply. Accept non-verbal communication. Don’t pressure them to speak.
3. Telegraphic and formulaic speech Single words, short phrases like “me go” and memorised chunks like “my turn” or “look at me”. Celebrate every attempt. Model slightly longer phrases back.
4. Productive language The child builds their own sentences, with mistakes that show they’re working out the rules. Respond to the meaning. Model correct forms naturally in conversation.

What’s Happening Inside a Quiet Multilingual Child

From the outside, the silent period can look like nothing is happening. From the inside, a lot is going on. This table sets out how adults sometimes read a quiet child, and what may really be happening.

What You Might See What Adults Sometimes Think What May Really Be Happening
Standing at the edges “She’s shy and can’t make friends.” Watching how the room works and looking for a safe way in.
Not answering questions “He doesn’t understand anything.” Understanding more each day, but not ready to speak yet.
Copying other children “She’s just following along.” Learning routines by watching, which is clever and useful.
Talking a lot at home “He’s fine at home, so why not here?” Home is where they feel safe to use language. That’s a good sign.
Being very tired after school “It’s just a long day.” Listening hard in a new language all day is exhausting.

That last one matters. Zara often came home very tired. Spending a whole day trying to understand a new language takes a lot of energy. Keeping our evenings calm, familiar and in Indonesian gave her a chance to recharge. I write more about after school crashes in regulation before learning.

How Long Does the Silent Period Last?

There’s no fixed answer. For many young children, it lasts a few weeks to several months. Some children speak English quite quickly, and others stay quiet for longer. Things that can make a difference include:

  • Personality: naturally cautious children often watch longer before speaking.
  • Age: younger and older children can approach a new language differently.
  • How much English they hear: more friendly, everyday English usually helps.
  • How safe they feel: warm relationships and familiar routines often shorten the quiet time.
  • Pressure: being pushed to speak can make some children quieter for longer.

Rather than watching the calendar, watch for progress. Is your child understanding more? Joining in more? Communicating in some way? Those are the signs that matter.

Silent Period or Something Else?

Most quiet EAL children are simply in the silent period. But sometimes silence has another cause, and it helps to know the difference so you can get support early. This table is a general guide, not a way to diagnose.

Silent Period Selective Mutism Language or Hearing Difficulty
Speaks at home? Yes, freely in the home language. Often yes, at home with family. May have difficulties in the home language too.
Communicates in other ways? Usually: points, nods, joins play. May freeze, avoid eye contact or seem very anxious. Varies.
Over time? Understanding and speaking slowly grow. Silence continues in certain places, even as English grows. Progress may be slow in every language.
Home language at school? Will often use it with a family member at school. May not speak at all at school, even in the home language or to a parent. Varies.

Selective mutism is an anxiety condition where a child who can speak doesn’t speak in particular settings, like school. It can be harder to spot in EAL children, because a quiet start is so normal. If your child’s silence goes on much longer than you’d expect, seems tied to fear, or you’re worried about their hearing, speech or development, talk with their educator and your GP, maternal and child health nurse, a speech pathologist or a psychologist. The GP Appointment Planner helps you bring clear notes.

It’s also worth knowing that some autistic children and children with language differences may be quiet for reasons that aren’t about learning English. If you notice differences in play, communication or social connection in your home language as well, a developmental check can help.

How to Support the Silent Period at Home

Idea 1

Keep Your Home Language Rich

Keep talking, reading, singing and telling stories in your home language. It’s where your child can use all their words, and it keeps their thinking and language growing while English catches up. Jim Cummins suggests that what children learn in one language supports learning in another.[3] You don’t need to switch to English at home.

Idea 2

Take the Pressure Off

Try not to ask your child to “say something in English” for visitors or teachers. Instead, talk about their day without expecting answers, and accept whatever they offer. If they share an English word, respond to the meaning with delight.

Idea 3

Keep After School Calm

A snack, quiet time and familiar routines help a tired child recharge. Long question sessions about the day can wait. Calm, wordless tools like our Calm Shapes Breathing Cards can help with big after school feelings.

Idea 4

Make English Playful and Low Stakes

English songs, picture books, cartoons in moderation and simple games at home give your child a relaxed way to hear more English. Children often try new words first in play, where there’s no pressure to get it right.

Idea 5

Share What You See With Educators

Let your child’s educators know how much your child talks at home, what they enjoy and a few key words in your language. It helps them see the whole child. The Home and Kinder Snapshot makes this simple.

How Educators Can Support the Silent Period

Talk Without Demanding Answers

Narrate what the child is doing in simple, warm words: “You’re building a tall tower. Red block, blue block.” This gives them English linked to real actions, with no pressure to reply. Ask questions that can be answered with a point or a nod: “Do you want the red one or the blue one?”

Use Visuals and Routines

Picture routines, gestures and clear, repeated phrases help a child understand what’s happening without needing all the words. Our visual routine cards and First Then Reset Mats help children see what comes next, and visual routine cards for ADHD kids explains how to use them for any child.

Pair Them With a Friendly Buddy

A kind, patient classmate can help a quiet child join play without needing to speak. If another child shares their home language, that can be a great comfort, though it’s best not to rely on one child as a translator.

Give Extra Wait Time

When you do invite a response, wait longer than feels natural. Many EAL children need extra time to understand, find a word and gather the courage to say it.

Welcome the Home Language

Let children use their home language with family or friends in the room, and learn a few words yourself. It shows them their language belongs, and it helps them feel safe enough to try English. The EAL identity and belonging guide has a key words card for educators and a printable belonging circle.

Observe and Note Progress

Note small signs of progress: following a routine, joining play, a new gesture, a first word. These help you and the family see how far the child has come. The What I’m Noticing Diary works well for this.

Useful First Phrases for EAL Children

Children coming out of the silent period often start with chunks of language they’ve heard many times. Teaching a few useful phrases through routines and play gives them a way in. Families can practise these at home too.

Phrase Why It Helps A Gesture to Pair With It
“Help please.”Asks for help with anything.Hands out, palms up.
“Toilet please.”One of the most important phrases in the first weeks.A simple sign agreed with the educator.
“My turn.”Joins games and sharing.Hand on chest.
“Can I play?”Opens the door to friendships.Point to the game.
“Stop.”Keeps them safe and sets boundaries.Hand up.
“Look at me.”Shares something they’re proud of.Point to themselves.
“I’m finished.”Helps with transitions.Hands flat, moving apart.

A Low Pressure Week of English for a Quiet Child

If you’d like a gentle plan, try one small, playful English moment each day, alongside plenty of home language. None of these ask your child to speak. They simply let English become familiar and fun. Five or ten minutes is plenty.

Day Low Pressure English Moment Why It Helps a Quiet Child
MondaySing one simple English song with actions, like “Heads, Shoulders, Knees and Toes”.Actions let them join in without words, and songs often come before speech.
TuesdayRead a picture book and point to things as you name them.Links English words to pictures, with no questions to answer.
WednesdayPlay “find the…” around the house: “Find something red.”They show understanding by finding, not by speaking.
ThursdayCook something simple and name each step: “Pour. Stir. Taste.”Short, repeated words tied to real actions.
FridayPlay a sound game from the Sound Hunt Cards.Builds listening for English sounds in a playful way.
WeekendGo somewhere familiar, like the park or the shops, and name a few things you see.Connects English to the places in their expanding world.

If your child joins in with a word, wonderful. If they just watch, that’s wonderful too. Watching is learning.

What Not to Do During the Silent Period

  • Don’t force speaking: “Say it or you can’t have it” often deepens silence and worry.
  • Don’t talk about the child as if they can’t understand: they often understand much more than they can say.
  • Don’t drop the home language: it’s where your child’s richest thinking and connection live.
  • Don’t compare: every child’s timeline is different, even within the same family.
  • Don’t label them: calling a child “the shy one” can stick and shape how they see themselves.

Signs the Silent Period Is Ending

The end of the silent period is often gradual and easy to miss. Watch and celebrate when you notice:

  • Single words: “Here.” “Mine.” “Water.”
  • Memorised chunks: “My turn.” “Look at me.” “Can I play?”
  • Short telegraphic sentences: “Me go park.” “No like.”
  • Mixing languages: an English word in an Indonesian sentence, or the other way round. This is normal and clever.
  • Singing along: many children sing English songs before they speak English sentences.
  • Talking to toys or themselves: private practice in English often comes before public speaking.

For Zara, one of the first was a single, quiet “Here” as she passed a classmate the scissors. It didn’t sound like much. To me, it meant everything. Early writing often grows at the same time, and you can see how in invented spelling in early EAL and drawing before writing.

Free Silent Period Printables for Parents and Educators

These free PDFs from this site help children understand routines without needing every word, give families and educators ways to share notes, and offer calm, wordless ways to express feelings.

Routine

Visual Routine Cards

Pictures that show the day, so a child can follow along before they understand all the words.

Download PDF For home and rooms
Next steps

First Then Reset Mats

“First this, then that” in pictures. Clear without needing English.

Download PDF For home and rooms
Routine

Daily Routine Chart

Everyday pictures to talk about at home in both languages.

Download A4 PDF Best for families
Sharing

Home and Kinder Snapshot

Share how much your child talks at home, and key words in your language.

Download PDF For families and educators
Noticing

What I’m Noticing Diary

Note small signs of progress, from gestures to first words.

Download PDF For home and rooms
If you’re worried

GP Appointment Planner

Get your notes ready before talking with a GP or specialist about long silence.

Download PDF Best for families
Identity

“All About Me” Storybook

Draw and share about home and family, with or without words.

Download A4 PDF For home and rooms
Feelings

“Big Feelings” Storybook

Draw feelings first, a gentle way to share without needing English.

Download A4 PDF For home and rooms
Calm

Calm Shapes Breathing Cards

A wordless way to calm big feelings after a long day of listening.

Download A4 PDF For home and rooms
Listening

Sound Hunt Cards

Playful listening games that build English sounds with no pressure to speak.

Download PDF For home and rooms
Draw and label

Draw It, Name It

Draw first. Label later, in either language, when they’re ready.

Download PDF For home and rooms
Family talk

Interview My Mum Keepsake

Home language conversations that keep family stories flowing.

Download PDF Best for families

For a printable belonging circle, see EAL identity and belonging. More free tools are on our printables page.

Looking Back

Those quiet months felt very long to me at the time. Now I see them as a season of listening. Zara was taking in sounds, routines, faces and friendships, all while holding on to the safety of home.

If your child is in their own silent period right now, it’s okay to feel worried. Keep your home language warm, keep pressure low, and watch for the small signs of progress. Their words are on their way. Years later, I watched my nephew in Indonesia take his own path into English through his love of science, which I wrote about in a child learning English as a second language. Every child finds their own way.

More From Our EAL Story Series

Silent Period FAQs

What is the silent period?

The silent period, also called the non-verbal period, is a time when a young child learning a new language listens and watches far more than they speak. They may communicate with gestures, pointing or their home language, while quietly building understanding of the new language before they start using it.

How long does the silent period last?

It varies a lot. For many young children it lasts a few weeks to several months, and some children skip it altogether. Age, personality, how much English they hear and how safe they feel all play a part. What matters most is that the child is communicating in some way and slowly understanding more.

Should I make my child speak English during the silent period?

No. Pressure to speak usually makes children more anxious and quieter. It helps more to keep talking warmly, accept pointing and gestures, offer simple choices, and keep the home language strong. Most children start speaking the new language when they feel ready and safe.

How is the silent period different from selective mutism?

In the silent period, a child is still learning the new language and usually communicates in other ways, and their speaking slowly grows. Selective mutism is an anxiety condition where a child who can speak consistently does not speak in certain settings, often looks frozen or anxious, and may not speak even their home language there. If silence lasts a long time or you are worried, talk with your GP, a psychologist or a speech pathologist.

What are the first signs the silent period is ending?

Children often start with single words, short chunks they have heard many times like “my turn” or “look at me”, and short telegraphic sentences like “me go park”. Mixing words from both languages is also common. These are all good signs and worth celebrating warmly.

How to read this page

Research and guidance: Tabors’ research on young children learning English, Krashen’s affective filter idea (popular but debated), Cummins on bilingual learning, and the Early Years Learning Framework.

Experience: Zara’s story is from our family. The tables, home ideas, educator ideas and first phrases come from my life and practice. The “silent period or something else” table is a general guide and can’t diagnose anything.

This is educational content, not speech pathology, psychology or medical advice. Last reviewed: 8 November 2026.

Readings That Guided My Thinking

  1. Tabors, P. O. (2008). One child, two languages: A guide for early childhood educators of children learning English as a second language (2nd ed.). Paul H. Brookes.
  2. Krashen, S. (1982). Principles and practice in second language acquisition. Pergamon Press. [The affective filter hypothesis, widely used in teaching but debated in research.]
  3. Cummins, J. (2000). Language, power and pedagogy: Bilingual children in the crossfire. Multilingual Matters.
  4. Australian Government Department of Education. (2022). Belonging, being and becoming: The Early Years Learning Framework for Australia (V2.0). Available via ACECQA.

Similar Posts